Sony HDR-MV1 vs Zoom Q3HD: Comparison & Review of Music Video Recorders


Check out comparison of two best music video recorders Sony HDR-MV1 and Zoom Q3HD, as it will help you to decide whichever suits your needs at best.

Several camcorders are available in the market from the big names like Sony, Toshiba, Canon, etc. Some are more professional, others are consumer friendly or mainly designed to record music concerts. If you want to buy the best video camera and best camcorder right now, then you are at the right place. Here is given details about top selected two music video recorders – Sony HDR-MV1 and Zoom Q3HD, both can capture those life-defining moments in 1080p. Sony’s HDR-MV1 music video recorder is aimed specifically at musicians, and focused on applications where sound quality is more significant than video, putting together a compact HD camcorder with a high-quality portable audio recorder, while Zoom Q3HD is a versatile and useful pocket cam that delivers outstanding audio quality.

Compare Sony HDR-MV1 vs Zoom Q3HD

Sony HDR-MV1

HDR-MV1 Music Video Recorder has been designed mainly for musicians, who want to record and share live – or staged – performances. It lets artists to capture and share all the performance with outstanding image quality Full HD and dynamic sound stereo studio quality. This device comes with a custom user interface designed mostly for the HDR-MV1 made to adjust and work with its different recording abilities.


The Video

Video is taken by a 120-degree wide-angle Carl Zeiss lens to make sure that all band members could be captured in the shot – at a resolution of either 1080p or 750p (both at 30 fps). A back-illuminated Exmor R CMOS sensor can take sharp images also in dimly-lit clubs, and the choice of manual exposure control will keep the iris from closing down every time. A lip sync feature is available to tie together your music and your performance. As with Sony’s latest introductions in the photo and video camera surroundings, this camera works with Wi-fi as well as NFC connectivity. Wi-Fi lets you to upload directly to a smartphone or tablet with the PlayMemories app from Sony, plus control the MV1 using a smartphone. NFC is useful for instant pairing with compatible devices.

The Audio

This device records audio in either uncompressed Linear PCM or internet-friendly AAC format, using a tunable 120-degree X-Y stereo microphone. You are able to control recording levels manually, and a line-in port is given for direct feeds. Audio quality can be monitored through user-supplied headphones, or with the camera’s built-in speaker.

Shots are monitored or reviewed with a 2.7-inch LCD screen, which can be even used to check and adjust audio input levels. Visit the website, if you want to purchase this device.

Zoom Q3HD

The Q3HD Handy Recorder obtains Zoom’s renowned audio technology and combines it with HD video, letting you to take every moment in sound and picture with superb clarity and resolution. The 2.4-inch LCD is pretty sharp and easily viewable outdoors. The device is very light, compared to other pocket cams, and truly has the feel of a toy instead of a piece of equipment. Operation is very simple, similar to other pocket cams: you have a big red button for starting and stopping the recording, a d-pad nearby it, and buttons for mode, menu, and delete. The video quality is very good and you get the option of recording in all the well-known HD resolutions – 1080p at 30 frames per second, 720p at 60 and 30 or widescreen standard-definition at 60 or 30 frames per second.

The $299 Q3HD Hand Video Recorder provides enhanced stereo audio control and quality for those who require it. The major attraction of the device is its built-in microphones, which give incredible audio quality. The two condenser mics’ “120 X/Y” pattern (the microphones are put besides each other and angled in contrary directions) let the camcorder to choose sounds in various directions – when combined together in playback, they generate stereo audio that provides good depth.

Table showing comparison of Sony HDR-MV1 and Zoom Q3HD:

Specs Sony HDR-MV1 Zoom Q3HD
Display 2.7″ (6.7cm) 230K Wide Clear Photo LCD(TM) (16:9) 2.4-inch full color LCD (QVGA)
Dimensions 116.5(W) × 70.5 (H) × 27(D) mm 51(W) x 132.9(D) x 23(H) mm
Weight 165 g (5.9 oz) (battery included) 105g (without battery)
Media type Memory Stick Micro (Mark 2)
Micro SD/SDHC/SDXC Memory Card (Class 4 or higher)
SD/SDHC card (up to 32GB)  (Class 4 or higher recommended)
Optics lens Carl Zeiss Tessar Lens, F2.8, f=2.5mm, FOV – 120° Fixed Focus (1.0m to infinity), F2.8
Video format MP4: MPEG-4 AVC/H.264 MPEG-4 AVC/H.264(MOV)
Video resolution MP4: 1920×1080 30p
MP4: 1280×720 30p
HD1080p 30fps, HD720p 60fps, HD720p 30fps, WVGA 60fps, WVGA 30fps
Audio format MPEG-4 AAC-LC 2ch
MPEG-4 Linear PCM 2ch (48kHz/16bit)
PCM (Quantization: 16/24bit, Sampling Frequency: 44.1/48/96kHz)
AAC (Bit Rate: 48 to 320kbps, Sampling Frequency: 48kHz)
Imaging sensor 1/2.3 type (7.77 mm) back-illuminated “Exmor R” CMOS sensor 1/3.2-inch 5M pixels CMOS sensor
Power Requirements 3.6V (battery pack); 5.0V (AC Adaptor) 2 x AA batteries (LR6 or Ni-MH)
AC adapter(AD-14): DC5V/1A/center positive